Dumme is a straightforward clip extraction tool. What it lacks: viral scoring, Telegram integration, and the editing depth that creators need to compete on short-form.
3.7★
Dumme rating
G2
4.9★
POMS rating
Early access users
$25/mo
Dumme pricing
Entry plan
What Dumme users complain about
No viral scoring or clip quality reasoning — you get clips but no signal on which to use.
Editor is too basic for creators who want to compete on caption quality and effects.
No Telegram or messaging bot — requires a browser session for every job.
Clip selection can feel arbitrary without quality-based detection logic.
No permanent storage guarantee on lower plans.
Limited export format options compared to more mature tools.
Feature for feature
| Feature | POMS | Dumme |
|---|---|---|
| Viral score breakdown | 5 dimensions | |
| Telegram bot | ||
| Permanent storage | Limited | |
| Twitch VOD support | ||
| Effects and stickers | ||
| Word-level caption edit | ||
| Credit refund on failure | ||
| Quality-based clip count | ||
| AI reframe to 9:16 | ||
| Auto captions | ||
| Free tier | 3 jobs | Trial |
Honest verdict
Dumme does the basics and little else. For creators who want to understand why clips were selected, edit captions word-by-word, and run jobs from Telegram at midnight after a stream, POMS is the more complete tool.
Where Dumme wins
Where POMS wins
3 jobs free. No credit card. No Dumme import needed — just paste a URL.
Get started free